Motions before the Council

Six theses standing for committee review. The dial shows the council's conviction; the band around it shows where members disagree.

Quorum 4 of 4 · Session opens 26 April 09:00 EDT

Motion · EV-CHG · t1

The depot is the moat.

0.78conviction

Average 0.78

Median 0.79

Dispersion (σ) 0.06

Range 0.68 — 0.82

Quorum 4 of 4

Advance threshold met: avg ≥ 0.70 ✓ · σ ≤ 0.10 ✓ · ≥ 3 endorsements ✓.
Council advised to proceed to Pursuing contingent on Hartwell's hold being released.

Members & Standing

0.82endorse

Mei-Lin ChengChair · Author

"Window of advantage is the operative variable; everything else is execution."18 April · primary author

0.74endorse w/ cond

Rashida OkaforStrategy

"Subject to cannibalization peer review (12 May). I will not support sizing beyond $1.0B until cleared."19 April · 1 condition outstanding

0.68defer

Lucia HartwellMarkets

"The thesis is sound. The timing argument depends on the Voltaira mark; I want one more independent confirmation before LOI."20 April · hold lifted upon receipt of SIG-2438

0.82endorse

Sanjay PatelOperations

"Agree with the verdict and the size envelope. No additional notes."19 April · clean endorsement

EV-CHG · t1 · cast your vote

How much conviction will you register?

Council conventions: a number, a sentence, and a position you can defend in the room.

Conviction (0 — 100)

DeclineDeferEndorse w/ condEndorseChampion

One-sentence rationale

Position

0.82M. Cheng

0.74R. Okafor (cond)

0.68L. Hartwell (defer)

0.82S. Patel

Casting raises the council average from 0.77 → 0.78 (σ steady).